SAN JOSÉ, CA.— Setting a world record while winning the 200 meter gold would be the pinnacle of most athletic careers. But Tommie Smith’s greatest triumph became a footnote the moment he untied his cleats.
While standing atop the Olympic podium in Mexico City, Smith and his training partner, bronze medalist John Carlos, placed their shoes to the side, revealing black socks worn during their winning dash. Then, as the Star Spangled Banner played, the two Americans, each wearing black gloves, raised their fists in the air and, according to sportswriter Dave Zirin, “created what must be considered the most enduring, riveting image in the history of either sports or protest.”
As San José State University (SJSU) students, Smith and Carlos were early members of the Olympic Project for Human Rights (OPHR), which organized athletes, contending for human rights across the world. The OPHR was founded in 1967 by Harry Edwards—a sociologist and record-setting discus thrower at SJSU—whose name is also synonymous with the history of global protest in sport. His 1969 book, The Revolt of the Black Athlete, is regarded as a groundbreaking analysis of the overlap between sports, politics, and race, catapulting his career as an academic and commentator.
You could know nothing about track and field, the 1968 Games, or even the names Smith, Carlos, and Edwards to be passively familiar with the dynamic image of two young, Black men making a silent gesture defying the racial terror that defined Black American life. But, Carlos wrote in his autobiography, The John Carlos Story, “this wasn't just about Black America.” Rather, Carlos said their cause extended beyond their troubles at home, but “standing with the struggles in apartheid nations fighting for their freedom."
In 2024, a new protest against international apartheid erupted at SJSU, furious with an administration they believed was complicit. Joining waves of protests emerging across college campuses throughout the United States, students from Smith and Carlos’ alma mater formed a 24/7 tent encampment at the Victory Salute sculpture, a statue commissioned by students petitioning the school for a monument that could “be an inspiration to other students” and “prove to them they can make an impact now.”
For these students, their “now” was Israel’s war in Gaza,1 ongoing occupation of Palestinians, and the school’s alleged ties to a country credibly accused of genocide.

San José State University president Cynthia Teniente-Matson (left) posing with an IDF soldier while visiting Israel. (Facebook)
Days later, students learned that the men commemorated by the statue they rallied around allegedly opposed their efforts. On May 15, Edwards began circulating a letter signed by himself, Smith, Carlos and Ken Noel—a lead organizer of the OPHR—denouncing the student-led anti-genocide protest. The four activists statement demanded the encampment be “totally dismantled” and “removed immediately,” condemning the protestor’s use of “flags and other political paraphernalia.”
Though the esteemed activists’ claimed to agree with the student’s call for a ceasefire, they argued that when students placed posters and flags on the Smith-Carlos sculpture calling for a ceasefire, their actions “approach desecration of the statue and the Movement it has come to represent and symbolize.” Despite claiming conditional support for some of the student protest’s aims, Edwards collaborated closely with a university leadership so hostile to its campus Gaza protests, that university president Cynthia Teniente-Matson facilitated the school’s firing of a tenured academic—justice studies professor Sang Hea Kil—over her participation in the encampment.
Regardless of Edwards’ perspective on the protest, his response delivered to the SJSU community was not created in collaboration with university leadership, and specifically, a university . eyeblack obtained an email from Teniente-Matson to Edwards asking the scholar and activist—along with his “infamous colleagues,2 Tommie [Smith], John Carlos and Ken [Noel]”—address an anti-war protest she described to him as a “public desecration of the most visible symbol of peaceful protest on the campus.”
Edwards obliged. Students removed their flags from the Victory Salute the next day. The revolt of the Black athletes was a success.
Who owns the Victory Salute?

Teniente-Matson, who joined the school as university president, began her request to Edwards by drawing from an earlier, in-person meeting between the two regarding “the recent protests and encampments adjacent to the Victory Salute Statutes [sic].” Framing herself as an “advocate for freedom of expression, peaceful protest, and all forms of civil discourse,” Teniente-Matson nonetheless argued the students’ speech, specifically, “the placement of paraphernalia and affixation of items to the statutes [sic],” threatened the monument in an email you can read for free.
When our reporting is based on newly obtained public records, we provide to the public. You, yes you, can read Teniente-Matson’s email to Edwards asking for his statement about Gaza protests, in full, for free by signing up for eyeblack.


